Showing posts with label Egypt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Egypt. Show all posts

Monday, June 3, 2013

The All Egypt Edition

Hola darlings!

Egyptian antiquities have been in the news quite a bit recently.  Here is a quick review.  Click on a particular link to read more:

Interview with Hawi Zahass at The Smithsonian Online.  I read it through, but not thoroughly.  Well worth the read - lots of fascinating information in it!

The Rise and Fall and Rise of Zahi Hawass
  • By Joshua Hammer
  • Smithsonian magazine, June 2013

    You all have probably heard about this right now, but Explorator conveniently compiled related links regarding the discovery of, reporting on, apology for, attempted (but failed) restoration and, so they now claim, a successful removal of the grafiti.  Yeah, like I believe the pathetic schmucks running ANYTHING in Egypt right now?  NOT!

  • A Chinese tourist defaced an image of Alexander the Great in a temple
    in Luxor:

    http://english.ahram.org.eg/NewsContent/9/40/72467/Heritage/Ancient-Egypt/Chines\
    e-tourist-scribbles-name-on-ancient-Luxor-Te.aspx

    http://tv.ibtimes.com/officials-forced-restore-egyptian-relic-after-teen-graffit\
    is-name-11337

    http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/foreigners/2013/05/ding_jinhao_d\
    efaced_the_luxor_temple_writing_graffiti_on_egyptian_pyramids.html

    http://edition.cnn.com/2013/05/27/travel/china-egypt/?sr=google_news&google_edit\
    ors_picks=true

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-china-22677980
    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2331613/China-disgraced-tourist-vandal-e\
    ngraved-Ding-Jihao-hieroglyphics-Egyptian-temple.html?ns_mchannel=rss&ns_campaig\
    n=1490

    http://www.globaltimes.cn/content/785075.shtml#.Uajyqdj4JVU
    http://www.artdaily.com/index.asp?int_sec=2&int_new=62890#.Uaj5n9j4JVU
    http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/letters/la-le-0601-saturday-egypt-graffiti-2\
    0130601,0,4764462.story


    … and his parents later apologized :

    http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_slatest/2013/05/27/ding_jinhao_chinese_parents_ap\
    ologize_for_teen_s_egypt_graffiti.html?wpisrc=newsletter_jcr:content

    http://www.newsdaily.com/article/c86c1303cdc6281f3ae2c1e08b4ce61d/nile-relic-van\
    dal-hunted-down-in-china


    … and there was a followup piece on graffiti on Egyptian monuments:

    http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/foreigners/2013/05/ding_jinhao_d\
    efaced_the_luxor_temple_writing_graffiti_on_egyptian_pyramids.html

    A sensationalistic article (one of a great deal of coverage on the discovery) about the first evidence of child abuse in ancient Egypt -- from an oasis late in the empire that was basically overrun by Romans and was "Christian."  Frankly, I'm skeptical that the child was actually Egyptian:

    Earliest Case of Child Abuse Discovered in Egyptian Cemetery

    Date: 28 May 2013 Time: 08:24 AM ET


    Lots of news about the well-noted decline in tourism in Egypt since the Muslim Brotherhood took the government over.  Well, what the hell did they expect!  Unemployed thugs and the desperate who do not realize or do not care just how much damage they are doing to their country are out in the streets daily, maybe some of them paid by the struggling government and the rest are just - you know - stupid, protesting and shouting ceaselessly "DEATH TO AMERICA."  Even CNN doesn't report on these schmucks any more, everyone rolls their eyes and spends their money elsewhere. Free-spending, big-spending American tourists are avoiding Egypt en masse these days.  Does the Brotherhood really think Chinese tourists will make up the shortfall?  LOL!

    Egypt's tourism still in decline after uprising
    Sarah Lynch, Special for USA TODAY
    12:17 a.m. EDT April 4, 2013

    Tourism in Egypt: Hope amid a slow recovery
    By Orlando Crowcroft, for CNN
    updated 7:19 AM EDT, Thu May 23, 2013

    Wondering if anyone else found this as hysterically funny as I did, LOL! 

    'It's just business' says minister on phobia of Iranian tourists in Egypt
    Dalia Farouk and Ahram Online , Saturday 1 Jun 2013

    And if anyone really believes the government that the tourist traps along the Red Sea will still be welcoming Europeans and others with open arms, and bikinis will not be banned and booze will continue to be served - just wait until they read this article.  And the authorities are writing this off to an "inexperienced" security officer.  Hmmmmm....

    Al-Arabiya,

    Tuesday, February 22, 2011

    Egypt, Egypt, Egypt!

    [D]amage to Egypt's heritage may have been greater than previously thought, as officials reported new cases of break-ins at archaeological sites...

    Well, I figured the archaeologists who were out in the field weren't lying about what was going on. Now we know.

    February 17, 2011
    AP
    King Tut's stolen dad found; Egypt sites to open  The good news is that the small (about a foot tall)  Akhenaten has been recovered!

    From Science
    Egypt's Hawass Fires Back at Critics
    by Andrew Lawler on 22 February 2011, 12:02 PM

    More on Akhenaten's statue recovered
    Priceless Pharaoh Statue Found Near Garbage Can
    February 17, 2011
    Discovery News

    Egyptians have launched a variety of "Come Back to Egypt" campaigns on the internet and social media, which is really cool! More power to them, but will tourists be so ready to come back so quickly?

    'Come back to Egypt' campaigns aim to attract tourists, Egyptian expats
    Thu, 17/02/2011 - 12:36
    Heba Helmy
    Almasryalyoum English Edition

    Sunday, February 13, 2011

    Egypt: Update on Looting and Thefts of Antiquities

    From Yahoo News/AP

    18 items missing from Egyptian Museum after unrest
    By JASON KEYSER, Associated Press Jason Keyser, Associated Press – 17 mins ago
    February 13, 2011

    CAIRO – A full inventory of the Egyptian Museum has found that looters escaped with 18 items during the anti-government unrest, including two gilded wooden statues of famed boy king, Tutankhamun, the antiquities chief said Sunday.

    The 18-day uprising that forced out President Hosni Mubarak engulfed the areas around the famed museum, on the edge of Cairo's Tahrir Square. On Jan. 28, as protesters clashed with police early on in the turmoil and burned down the adjacent headquarters of Mubarak's ruling party, a handful of looters climbed a fire escape to the museum roof and lowered themselves on ropes from a glass-paneled ceiling onto the museum's top floor.

    Around 70 objects — many of them small statues — were damaged, but until Sunday's announcement, it was not known whether anything was missing.

    Antiquities Minister Zahi Hawass said the museum's database department determined 18 objects were gone. Investigators searching for those behind the thefts were questioning dozens of people arrested over several days after last month's break-in.

    The most important of the missing objects is a limestone statue of the Pharaoh Akhenaten, the so-called heretic king that tried to introduce monotheism to Egypt, standing and holding an offering table.

    "It's the most important one from an artistic point of view," said museum director Tarek el-Awady. "The position of the king is unique and it's a beautiful piece of art." During Akhenaten's so-called Amarna period, named after his capital, artists experimented with new styles.

    Also gone is a gilded wooden statue of the 18th Dynasty King Tutankhamun, Akhenaten's son, being carried by a goddess. Pieces are also missing from another statue of the boy king wielding a fishing harpoon from a boat.

    "We have the boat and the legs of the king, but we are missing other parts of the body," el-Awady said. "We are looking everywhere for them — around the museum, outside, on the roof, from where the thieves got into the museum."

    He said none of the missing objects was from the gated room containing the gold funerary mask of King Tutankhamun and other stunning items from his tomb in the Valley of the Kings — the museum's chief attractions. The looters did not break into the room, he said.

    The other missing items are a statue of Nefertiti, Akhenaten's wife, making offerings, a sandstone head of a princess and a stone statuette of a scribe from Amarna, and a heart scarab and 11 wooden funerary statuettes of the nobleman Yuya.

    Antiquities authorities also announced Sunday that thieves broke into a storage site at the royal necropolis of Dahshur, south of Cairo, on Feb. 11. They had no information yet on whether items were missing.

    The Egyptian Museum remains closed and guarded by an army unit, but workers are cleaning the vast building and the garden around it. Efforts are being made to improve security.

    Saturday, February 12, 2011

    What's Going On In Egypt?

    I pegged this guy a few days ago as a gutsy guy in a private email to Mr. Don as we were following live news broadcasts via BBC online and I was freaking out about the possibility of massive violence come Friday (2 - or is it 3? - days ago) after President Mubarak gave his speech and it was clear that he had no intention (then) of standing down.  I was walking around the office wondering - why aren't these people freaking out like I am?  Don't they know what's going on?  Don't they care?  If they know - do they really think events in Egypt won't affect them, one way or another? Oh Goddess...

    Tonight I saw his name come up again in this article:

    Hossam Badrawi, a stalwart of Mubarak's National Democratic Party, met with Mubarak on Thursday and later told reporters that he expected the Egyptian leader to "meet people's demands" — read that stepping down — later the same day. After Mubarak did not, Badrawi, who had been named the party's secretary general a few days earlier, resigned in protest, according to two party insiders.

    Is he real, or is he Memorex?  Only the Egyptian people know for sure -- stay tuned.

    The National Geographic Says - No Looting of Maya Tombs

    Here's what the NG blog says:

    Report From Saqqara: Contrary to Rumor, the Two 'Maya' Tombs Are Safe
    Posted Feb 9,2011

    After looters swarmed the ancient burial ground at Saqqara on January 29, panic swept the world of Egyptology. One online group reported that looters had entered and “destroyed” the interiors of “many tombs.” On the Facebook group “Egyptologists for Egypt,” a contributor wrote that the tomb of Maya, in particular, “is destroyed and even the reliefs in the burial chamber have been hacked out.” As that rumor spread, there was confusion about which Maya tomb—there are two at Saqqara. Some reported that it was the tomb belonging to King Tutankhamun's wet nurse (whose name is often spelled Maia); others said it was that of Tut’s treasurer.


    It turns out the reports were grossly exaggerated. The tomb of the wet nurse is still sealed with bricks. And on Tuesday, inspectors at Saqqara led me into Maya the treasurer’s burial chamber. “Nobody touched the tomb here, “ said Mohammad Mohammad Youssef, chief inspector for South Saqqara, as he and a colleague broke a wire and seal on the metal door leading underground. “We put seals on the lock about a month ago when we checked it for humidity and temperature, and the same seals were still here and the locks were not broken.” Youssef and I walked down a tight, sandy staircase of a dozen steps to an iron gate with another three locks on it, and another seal that was untouched after the looting. Then we entered three chambers, over 3,000 years old, shimmering with golden-yellow reliefs.


    The reliefs are from the Amarna period, about 3,350 years ago, when wall paintings were more naturalistic than in other pharaonic eras. They show the treasurer and his wife with various gods, including Osiris, god of the afterlife; Isis, goddess of motherhood and fertility; Ptah, god of creation; and Anubis, the jackal-headed god who oversees mummification. Maya "is praying to these different gods, meaning that he has good relations with all of the gods, who will be with him in the afterlife,” said government Egyptologist Ashraf Mohiee.


    Aboveground, looters broke into several small storerooms, which hold bones, shards of pottery, and other collected items. The treasure hunters rifled through a portion of this material, tossing items on the floor. “We’ll lose some archaeological information if it’s a mess inside,” Maarten Raven, who leads the Dutch expedition at the site, told me by phone from the Netherlands. “But it’s nothing major.” He expressed great relief that the tomb itself was fully intact.


    —Jeffrey Bartholet

    Truth? Lie? Somewhere in between? Cleary, something happened at Saqqara. I very much doubt that archaeologists and their workers were just making things up as they were emailing reports and blogging about tombs being broken into and looting taking place. They did not imagine those events!

    So what, really, happened? We will probably never know the full truth because the Egyptian government - however it is constituted now and in the future - will make sure we do not! Tourism in Egypt has already suffered a great heart-blow during the recent unrest that led to the ultimate resignation of President Mubarak. The authorities, whoever they may be, are not going to 'fess up to the wholesale rape of ancient antiquities! Billions of dollars are at stake - and I don't mean the billions that the illicitly stolen antiquities will ultimately fetch on the underground market.

    Catching Up -- What's Going on in Egypt!

    Hola darlings!

    I haven't abandoned the blog - I've just been so enthralled by what's been going on in Egypt -- and I've taken on a new family tree research project for a friend of a friend -- and today it's WARM outside.  Absolutely amazing - FINALLY above 32 degrees F!  After an early hike and back to the supermarket to stock up on essentials (wine, bread, meat, and nuts for the squirrels) I've been busy -- and the Christmas tree is still up, I haven't even attempted to start the project that is taking it down!

    So - in between bouts of working on this new family tree, and heaving tremendously huge blocks of snow (fortunately rendered maleable due to the temperature) over my shoulder in an attempt to at last clear my driveway of the accumulation from the Great Blizzard of 2011 -- working in shifts -- I'm taking a break now.

    Ancient Egypt was a land of goddesses.  I often wonder what happened in that twilight time between the "official" closing of the last temples in the 400's CE by orders of the Holy Roman Emperor who was, by that time, a nominal "Christian," and the 600's CE invasion by and takeover of Egypt by the Muslims and their new, fierce god, Allah, who was just a retred of the tired, old storm god of the Israelites, Yahweh. 

    Christianity did have a bulwark in Egypt, in the form of the Copts who, with their language, kept alive a link to the old hieratic form of writing, which was a "shorthand" for the even older hieroglyphics. A continuous chain to the ancient past. The Holy Mother Isis, and the creator-goddess Hathor (and perhaps the "archaic" creator-goddess, Neith), found much common ground with the Christian concept of the Holy Mother Mary.  And so, perhaps, the Egyptians of the time gave a new gloss to their old beliefs.  The Egyptians were very good at adopting and adapting foreign deities into their own religious pantheon and inconography.  

    Then, Islam came and presumably swept all away before it.  But - not quite... At the root of Islam (not talked about - perhaps not even generally known by the average Muslim)  is another ancient Mother Goddess - al-Alat.  And those Coptic Christians, they never went away, either.  They are still there -- a minority, to be sure, persecuted, to be sure.  For shame - Shame, Shame on the Egyptians of today for forgetting the lessons of their ancient and glorious past!  Tolerance - tolerance, acceptance, incorporation.  In ancient Egypt, there was room for all gods and goddesses.

    I don't know about you, but since the first outbreaks of protest marches in Egypt on January 25, 2011, I have been feverishly following the news and praying incessantly for those brave souls, just as I prayed incessantly for the brave souls in Iran in 2009, who were marching also - then - for freedom.  Interesting, isn't it, that Freedom is not a god, She's a Goddess.  She is a Mother - nurturing, protective, fierce when She needs to be.  Determined.  She Never Gives Up. 

    I followed the news online and on BBC news and other news shows on PBS on television over the last two plus weeks.  As the days went by, I got more and more wrought.  What would happen?  Reports were streaming in of people being killed by security forces and "unknown snipers" who were, presumably, also security forces of the Egyptian government.  Upwards of 500 people were killed during the - euphemistically called "unrest."  Yes - unrest.

    It brings me to tears just thinking about it.  People - today - dying for Freedom.  Let them not be forgotten. I do not know any of their names. I pray that their names will become known to all.  I pray that out of the new Egypt that emerges from the ashes of the old, a monument will rise to those people who were killed, and we the world over will be able to see their names, someday, engraved in stone that will last for 10,000 years, and more. 

    What will happen next?  I don't know - no one knows. Egypt, that most ancient land, has embarked upon a journey to a brave new world.  Let us all pray for her.  In the meantime, Egypt's people are stepping forward to help clean-up after days of confrontation, stress, hope and anger, and hope again and, predictably, no regular garbage pick-ups. Let us hope the new Egypt can fix their bureaucracy :)  For some reason, this photo (from The New York Times) gives me hope.

    Maybe, after all,  I will get to take that trip to see the Egyptian Museum before I'm too old and decrepit.  But not this year, darlings.  Not this year. 

    Sunday, January 30, 2011

    Reports on what is happening in Egypt from Egyptology Blog

    http://egyptology.blogspot.com/

    As you will see from the reports below, while the official Egyptian military and police are now always being deployed to protect (or doing their duty to protect) Egypt's priceless artifacts and memorials, everyday Egyptian citizens are stepping up to provide protection, in a heart-warming display of patriotism and love for their heritage that brings tears to my eyes. Here are some entries from the above-stated blog, copied in their entirety. For more news, please check in to Egyptology News:

    Sunday, January 30, 2011
    Updates as they trickle in
    21:15 - Thanks very much to a contact who has been on the phone to the Epigraphic Survey team at Chicago House (Oriental Institute in Luxor) and can confirm that as of a couple of hours ago they are safe. Good news. Although the State Department's official advice is that non-essential people should evacuate it's not clear if the survey people will be trying to leave or not.


    17:25 - An update from Zahi Hawass on his drhawass.com website, transferred by fax, shown here in full in case there are difficulties accessing it later on:


    On Friday, January 28, 2011, when the protest marches began in Cairo, I heard that a curfew had been issued that started at 6.00pm on Friday evening until 7.00am on Saturday morning. Unfortunately, on that day the Egyptian Museum, Cairo, was not well guarded. About a thousand people began to jump over the wall on the eastern side of the museum into the courtyard. On the western side of the museum, we recently finished something I was very proud of, a beautiful gift shop, restaurant and cafeteria. The people entered the gift shop and stole all the jewellery and escaped; they thought the shop was the museum, thank God! However, ten people entered the museum when they found the fire exit stairs located at the back of it.

    As every one knows, the Egyptian Museum, Cairo, is naturally lit and due to the architectural style of it, there are glass windows on its roof. The criminals broke the glass windows and used ropes to get inside, there is a distance of four metres from the ceiling to the ground of the museum. The ten people broke in when I was at home and, although I desperately wanted to go to the museum, I could not leave my house due to the curfew. In the morning, as soon as I woke up, I went directly there. When I arrived, I found out that, the night before, three tourist police officers had stayed there overnight because they were not able to get out before the curfew was put in place. These officers, and many young Egyptians who were also there, helped to stop more people from entering the museum. Thankfully, at 10.00pm on Friday night, the army arrived at the museum and gave additional security assistance.

    I found out that one criminal was still at the museum, too. When he had asked the people guarding the museum for water, they took his hands and tied him to the door that lead to the gift shop so that he could not escape! Luckily, the criminals who stole the jewellery from the gift shop did not know where the jewellery inside the museum is kept. They went into the Late Period gallery but, when they found no gold, they broke thirteen vitrines and threw the antiquities on the floor. Then the criminals went to the King Tutankhamun galleries. Thank God they opened only one case! The criminals found a statue of the king on a panther, broke it, and threw it on the floor. I am very thankful that all of the antiquities that were damaged in the museum can be restored, and the tourist police caught all of the criminals that broke into it. On Saturday, the army secured the museum again and guarded it from all sides. I left the museum at 3.00pm on Saturday, 29, 2011.

    What is really beautiful is that not all Egyptians were involved in the looting of the museum. A very small number of people tried to break, steal and rob. Sadly, one criminal voice is louder than one hundred voices of peace. The Egyptian people are calling for freedom, not destruction. When I left the museum on Saturday, I was met outside by many Egyptians, who asked if the museum was safe and what they could do to help. The people were happy to see an Egyptian official leave his home and come to Tahrir Square without fear; they loved that I came to the museum.

    The curfew started again on Saturday afternoon at 4.00pm, and I was receiving messages all night from my inspectors at Saqqara, Dahsur, and Mit Rahina. The magazines and stores of Abusir were opened, and I could not find anyone to protect the antiquities at the site. At this time I still do not know what has happened at Saqqara, but I expect to hear from the inspectors there soon. East of Qantara in the Sinai, we have a large store containing antiquities from the Port Said Museum. Sadly, a large group, armed with guns and a truck, entered the store, opened the boxes in the magazine and took the precious objects. Other groups attempted to enter the Coptic Museum, Royal Jewellery Museum, National Museum of Alexandria, and El Manial Museum. Luckily, the foresighted employees of the Royal Jewellery Museum moved all of the objects into the basement, and sealed it before leaving.

    My heart is broken and my blood is boiling. I feel that everything I have done in the last nine years has been destroyed in one day, but all the inspectors, young archaeologists, and administrators, are calling me from sites and museums all over Egypt to tell me that they will give their life to protect our antiquities. Many young Egyptians are in the streets trying to stop the criminals. Due to the circumstances, this behaviour is not surprising; criminals and people without a conscience will rob their own country. If the lights went off in New York City, or London, even if only for an hour, criminal behaviour will occur. I am very proud that Egyptians want to stop these criminals to protect Egypt and its heritage.

    At this time, the Internet has not been restored in Egypt. I had to fax this statement to my colleagues in Italy for it to be uploaded in London on my website.



    16:25 - Thanks very much to Kate's News from the Valley of the King's blog for an update on the JHU team from the temple of Mut, half of whom have left Luxor with the other half due to leave soon. Protests in Luxor still seem to be relatively low key by comparison with Cairo. If anyone has any other news about personnel in Egypt please let either Kate or I know so that we can let everyone else know. There is a great deal of concern out there.



    15:26 - Thanks to an anonymous commenter who pointed me to another German article, this time an interview with Wafaa el-Saddik on Zeist Online (and here in engine-English thanks to Google Translate). Of the Egyptian Museum she says that a total of 13 display cases were smashed, that, as she said earlier, looters have stolen pharaonic jewellry trinkets and that the new extension with the large souvenir shop, which was opened in November 2010, was totally robbed. As with the earlier article she identifies security guards and police as the perpetrators. She suggests that the reason that the security guards turned to theft is because of the seriously low salaries that they earn, unable to buy the basics for their families. She goes on to say that on Saturday morning the Memphis museum and magazine were emptied by thieves. She called the police, but they did not respond so she then alerted the army but by then it was too late. She phoned the museums in Luxor and Aswan but there was nothing happening at either at that time. She identifies that the lack of protection is a great problem but also that none of the museums in Egypt are insured. [Thanks to Daniel and Joris for checking the translation].



    15:01 - See Margaret Maitland's Eloquent Peasant blog for a list of all the identified artefacts that have been damaged in the Egyptian Museum in Cairo. Many of the comments are worth reading too. A really horrific inventory of broken pieces of priceless antiquity. Heartbreaking.



    13:35 - Thanks to Jane Akshar and her friend Colette for the latest (and just about the only) news from Luxor, via a recording of a phonecall between Colette and Jane, available on Jane's blog. Jane says that on the West Bank (where the mortuary temples and the Valley of the Kings are located) the police have abandoned the monuments so protection is being organized by local people who are taking measures to ensure that the sites are safe. There are no protests on the West Bank. On the East Bank, the main town of Luxor where the temples of Luxor and Karnak are located, there are low key protests being carried out but they are a very different kettle of fish from those in Cairo. Jane, her staff and all her guests are all perfectly safe.



    13:18 - Ismail Serageldin, Librarian of Alexandria and Director of the Bibliotheca (the New Library of Alexandria) has released a statement today to say that the library is currently protected on an informal basis:

    The library is safe thanks to Egypt’s youth, whether they be the staff of the Library or the representatives of the demonstrators, who are joining us in guarding the building from potential vandals and looters. I am there daily within the bounds of the curfew hours. However, the Library will be closed to the public for the next few days until the curfew is lifted and events unfold towards an end to the lawlessness and a move towards the resolution of the political issues that triggered the demonstrations.



    13:14 - Friends of Fekri Hassan and Geoffrey Tassie (Tass) will be relieved to know that Jo Rowland has spoken to them and that both are well. Thanks Jo - much appreciated.



    13:00 - The German newsaper Der Tagesspiegel (thanks Homer) via Google Translate says that the director of the Egyptian Museum, Wafaa el-Saddik, has told one of their journalists that security guards and police officers were responsible for the looting of the Egyptian Museum, apparently in two separate episodes. She is quoted saying that police had removed their jackets so as not to be identified as police officers. A second group of offenders apparently entered from the back of a fire escape through the skylight. El-Saddik goes on to describe how many artefacts were tossed on the floor and are damaged or destroyed, including statues of gods from the treasure of Tutankhamun. Contrary to Hawass's statement yesterday el-Saddik is quoted saying that looters had stolen pharaonic items. The article in the original German is here. UPDATED - Thanks to Joris Van Wetering for looking through the original German article. He says that the article adds that most of damage (objects being broken etc) was done on the first floor (erste stockewerke) and that Pharaonic Jewellery (smuckstucke) has been stolen.



    12.40 - The travel agency Thompson (the only UK company to fly direct to Aswan) has cancelled all outgoing flights from the UK to Aswan and Luxor, although empty planes are being sent to pick up returnees. No evacuations have been recommended for either town. Many flights to Cairo have been cancelled as well from the UK (source: The Independent's travel correspondent via BBC News 24). See Simon Calder's travel advice for the current situation in Egypt on The Independent's website, which points out that even where flights are still operating on the Cairo route they are severely disrupted due to requirements to land outside the times of the curfew.

    Egyptian Museum Looted - How Much Damage, Really???

    We don't know, and Zahi Hawass won't tell us any time soon.  I have read reports of "heads torn off mummies."  Holy Goddess!  I just do not understand how come the museum was not immediately shut down and protected by massive police and military presence when the protests first began, over a week ago? And why the most obvious targets of treasure hunters (Tut's gold, for instance) were not immediately smuggled out of the the museum and locked away in deep vaults somewhere.

    I have a great deal of respect for the Egyptian people and their ancient heritage - They are very different from the Arabs who today rule in much of the Middle East - but all it takes is a few foreign instigators to urge on some young hot-heads to loot and set fire to things and, suddenly, things get out of hand.  We've already seen that happening in Cairo. 

    Now, tonight on the NBC news broadcast was a report of wholesale looting of treasures from King Tut's exhibit - and much more damage to the museum and looting of its exhibits than has been reported in print that I saw!  It makes me sick to my stomach.  Oh my Goddess, please make it not be true.

    Already the average Egyptian, more than half of whom depend upon tourism to make their livings, must be feeling the pinch of thousands of tourists trying to flee home and the disruption of tours. What will happen to the Egyptian people during the next few years when tourists refuse to visit Egypt - already thousands of tourists are trying to flee the country, and I hope they all make it home safely.  If I were in their shoes, I'd be trying to run away too, as fast as I could! 

    I don't know what's going to happen in Egypt. I just want the violence and deaths to end - and the thiefs who are looting the ancient heritage of all the Egyptian people to be caught and prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law.

    Saturday, October 24, 2009

    Ancient Artififacts as Pawns in Blackmail

    Why I have no respect for Zahi Hawass -- Story from The International Herald Tribune When Ancient Artifacts Become Political Pawns By MICHAEL KIMMELMAN Published: October 23, 2009 BERLIN — As thousands lined up to catch a glimpse of Nefertiti at the newly reopened Neues Museum here, another skirmish erupted in the culture wars. Egypt’s chief archaeologist, Zahi Hawass, announced that his country wanted its queen handed back forthwith, unless Germany could prove that the 3,500-year-old bust of Akhenaten’s wife wasn’t spirited illegally out of Egypt nearly a century ago. “We’re not treasure hunters,” Mr. Hawass told Spiegel Online. “If it’s proven clearly that the work was not stolen,” he said. “there shouldn’t be any problem.” Then he said he was sure the work had been stolen. Globalization, it turns out, has only intensified, not diminished, cultural differences among nations. The forces of nationalism love to exploit culture because it’s symbolic, economically potent and couches identity politics in a legal context that tends to pit David against Goliath. Mr. Hawass also recently fired a shot at France, demanding the Louvre return five fresco fragments it purchased in 2000 and 2003 from a gallery and at auction. They belonged to a 3,200-year-old tomb near Luxor and had been in storage at the museum. Egypt had made the demand before, but this time suspended the Louvre’s long-term excavation at Saqqara, near Cairo, and said it would stop collaborating on Louvre exhibitions. France got the message. It promised to send the fragments back tout de suite. It didn’t go unnoticed in Paris, Berlin or Cairo that Mr. Hawass pressed his case about Nefertiti [image, above, from stock photo] and suspended the excavations by the Louvre just after his country’s culture minister, Farouk Hosny, bitterly lost a bid to become director general of the United Nations’ cultural agency, Unesco. The post went late last month to a Bulgarian diplomat instead. Mr. Hosny would have been the first Arab to land the job, and Egypt’s president, Hosni Mubarak, had banked a not insignificant amount of his own prestige on the minister’s getting it. But Jewish groups and prominent French and German intellectuals (not the Israeli government, though) campaigned against Mr. Hosny. When asked in Egypt’s Parliament last year about the presence of Israeli books in Alexandria’s library, Mr. Hosny said: “Let’s burn these books. If there are any, I will burn them myself before you.” That prompted Elie Wiesel, Claude Lanzmann and Bernard-Henri Lévy in Le Monde to urge that he not be selected, also quoting Mr. Hosny as saying in 2001, “Israeli culture is an inhuman culture” based on theft. After that Mr. Hosny told the same French newspaper that he was sorry for those remarks and “nothing is more distant to me than racism, the negation of others or the desire to hurt Jewish culture or any other culture.” Then he failed to get the job and blamed the failure on a Jewish conspiracy. “The conspiracy was bigger than you can imagine,” he told an Egyptian weekly. In fact, what may have ultimately done Mr. Hosny in, aside from his closeness to an old, tired, dictatorial regime, was his suspected role, as an Egyptian diplomat in 1985, in protecting the perpetrators of a terrorist attack on a cruise ship, the Achille Lauro, during which a Jewish American tourist in a wheelchair was shot and pushed into the sea. In any case, days after the Unesco decision, Mr. Hawass went after France and Germany. When questioned about the timing, he insisted there was no connection, saying he had asked the French to return the artifacts two months earlier. But that was when Mr. Hosny’s campaign had already started to fall apart. Likewise, Mr. Hawass had also said that his sudden announcement, in late August, of restoration work on an Egyptian synagogue had nothing to do with Mr. Hosny’s bid. It was just as clear back then that this was an attempt to assuage growing Jewish opposition to the minister. Over the years Egypt has occasionally made a bid for Nefertiti, when the political climate is ripe. Germans point out that Ludwig Borchardt, who discovered Nefertiti at Tel el Amarna in 1912, had Egyptian approval to take it to Berlin. Just the other day, Iraq repeated its demand that Germany return the Gate of Ishtar from the ancient city of Babylon, excavated and shipped to Berlin before World War I. In Iraq’s case, the government seems to be wagering that German ambivalence about the current war may help swing popular opinion here about giving back the gate, just as Saddam Hussein’s regime played the repatriation card in 2002 as a tactic in negotiating with the United Nations over letting weapons inspectors into the country. For the Egyptian public, Mr. Hosny’s defeat was another condemnation of the country’s stagnant leadership. “Defeat and failure and regression will keep following this regime, whose members’ policy is to stay in office forever,” wrote Muhsin Radi, a Muslim Brotherhood Member of Parliament, in the daily Al-Dustour. [Oh sure, so the Egyptians are supposed to turn the reins of the country over to YOU? Bwwwwwwaaaaaaahhhhhhaaaaaaaaa!] The country’s only potent weapon left may be antiquities. It plays to popular sentiment and national pride. While the art world likes to ponder the merits or misfortunes of seeing art from one place in another place or the inequities that have resulted from centuries of imperialist collecting, the real issue behind the Egyptian claims, as with so many others, is nationalism. Continued 2

    Wednesday, October 7, 2009

    Zahi Hawass Declares War

    In the days before this blog was started, in the old old days when people still used message boards, I used to refer to Mr. Hawass by various terms, all using ASS as a primary metaphor, and none of which received wide circulation. Times change, but ASSES do not. I cannot help but think that Mr. Hawass' latest declared wars on museums who possess Egyptian antiquities that Mr. Hawass thinks the current government of Egypt should possess will fail, and fail badly. Ultimately, this attempted blackmail will fail because Mr. Hawass cannot guarantee the safety of these antiquities once he dies - or, actually, even during his lifetime. What happens to these priceless artifacts if fundamentalist Muslims take over Egypt? We all witnessed what happened in Afghanistan when the Taliban took over, didn't we. The same kind of destruction of irreplaceable and priceless archaeological ruins and artifiacts is now going on in Iran, at official government sanction -- the official destruction of pre-Islamic Persian antiquities. It is done in the name of "building dams" and "building highways" - or whatever, but the end result is destruction of Persia's cultural heritage. This is going on in the United States, too. Contractors putting in roads, bridges, repaving highways, etc., on a daily basis, are deliberately ignoring national and local laws designed to preserve ancient heritage sites and uncovered relics. Whatever the motive, the result is the same. Permanent, irreplaceable destruction of the history of the world. Unfortunately, the Lourve and at least certain factions of the government of the Republic of France have caved into this blackmail. I say - well, you can can guess what I'd say! I don't think it will be that difficult, darlings! Long term, this is a badly losing gambit played by Mr. Hawass. What a shame.

    Sunday, June 14, 2009

    Egypt to Villagers: MOVE YOUR BUTTS!

    (Image: Old Qurna, from Tour Egypt, article by Lara Iskander, where she wrote: The old Gourna village is built over Pharaonic tombs, many of which were not discovered yet. The residents were famous for being able to bring up suspiciously authentic Egyptian monuments from their cellars. The antiquities [authorities] were having trouble controlling the tomb-robbing occurring in the areas of the Valley of the Kings, Queens and Nobles nearby. And so, the perfect solution seemed to be to move the seven thousand locals whose economy depended on tomb looting.) From the Times Online: June 13, 2009 Death of a village outside Luxor that lived off ancient tombs James Hider in Luxor Just outside the Valley of the Kings a set of ancient tombs has created a very modern controversy. Western archaeologists accuse the Egyptian Government of forcibly displacing thousands of people from a unique local community to open up the site as a new tourist attraction, while the authorities say that the villagers have damaged tombs and stolen mummies. The village of Qurna, on the outskirts of Luxor, arose more than a century ago when farmers on the banks of the Nile fled seasonal flooding and moved into the shelter of pharaonic tombs that dot the rocky bluffs above the river. People built elaborate houses of mud brick and wood around the caves and, with the advent of tourism, made a living showing visitors their in-house tombs and selling souvenirs. But five years ago President Mubarak decided that Luxor was becoming a slum, overrun with hawkers and unauthorised buildings that were obscuring and damaging its ancient treasures. He appointed a former army general, Samir Farrag, to clean up Luxor. “One of the first orders of the President was to transfer the people of Qurna,” said General Farrag, now the city’s governor. So arose the village of New Qurna, a grid of pink and cream concrete terraces farther into the desert, lacking the character of its predecessor but provided with running water, a post office, schools and sewerage for the 3,000 families moved there. Most families did not go willingly and they complain that the tiny modern houses have broken up traditional, sprawling households and squeezed them into stifling boxes with facilities scarcely better than those of their former primitive homes. “They just wanted us out. There’s no benefit for us to be here,” said Umm Mohammed Tayyeb, a mother of six, who complained that the water ran so infrequently that she had resorted to storing it in large earthenware urns, as she had done in the old village. Most villagers said that the authorities had forced them out of their old homes by turning off the electricity. More worryingly, some of the first houses built in New Qurna, two years ago, are already falling apart. “My kids sleep here — it could collapse on them,” said Ahmed Rustum, whose house, like those of his neighbours, is webbed with deep floor-to-ceiling cracks. [See, contra, this article at Tour Egypt, about how the village was designed and the materials used in its construction]. Some international experts on Egypt say that the Government is sacrificing a unique community to cash in on tourism. “The Egyptian authorities are now determined to sterilise the area, creating a kind of archaeological tourist park stripped of any trace of anything living or anything relating to the more modern [Roman onwards] history of the site,” said one expert from Britain, who asked not to be named for fear of being banned from the country. Ahmed Tayyeb, who earns his living by restoring tombs, denied that the old villagers had damaged the burial sites. He said that bull- dozers used to demolish many of the houses probably did far more damage, although General Farrag insisted that houses over tombs were demolished by workers using only sledgehammers. “It destroyed a unique way of life,” Mr Tayyeb said. Sabah Mahmoud, a resident of Qurna, said the international community had done nothing to protect the villagers, including the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation (Unesco), which has deemed the huge temple at nearby Karnak a World Heritage Site. “Unesco is asleep,” he said. [Is it UNESCO's responsibility to protect illegal squatters, even if they have been there 100 years?] The controversy over Luxor may hurt Egypt’s nomination of its former Culture Minister, Farouq Hosni, as the next head of Unesco. Mr Hosni’s campaign is already faltering after it emerged that he had publicly called for the burning of Hebrew language books in the Alexandria library. But Zahi Hawass, the head of the Egyptian Supreme Council for Antiquities, backs the Government. He said that Qurna residents had stolen treasures from the graves and even hidden mummies to display to tourists for cash. “Not all of these were good people. Some of them destroyed inside the tombs,” he said. Under the plans, a handful of the houses in Old Qurna will remain standing over their ancient tombs and be open to tourists. One is still inhabited by Umm Sayyid, a 76-year-old woman who was born and married in it and brought up her children and grandchildren there. She was unsentimental about moving, saying she would be ready to move if offered decent housing. One of her daughters muttered: “Don’t listen to what the men say. This house is too much work.”

    Thursday, March 5, 2009

    More Egypt Photos from Carmen

    Alexandria Biblioteca, el exterior
    Edificio auxliar al lado de la Biblioteca

    Saturday, February 14, 2009

    More Egypt Pictures from Carmen

    Christmas trip, December, 2008: Scenes from Abu Simbel

    Thursday, February 12, 2009

    Tutankhamen Statue Found in Kurdistan

    From monstersandcritics.com Middle East News Found in Iraq: King "Tut" Feb 12, 2009, 16:48 GMT Dohuk, Iraq - A Kurdish archaeological expedition announced on Thursday that it had found a small statue of the ancient Egyptian pharaoh Tutankhamen in northern Iraq, a Kurdish news agency reported. Hassan Ahmed, the director of the local antiquities authority, told the Kurdish news agency Akanews that archaeologists had found a 12-centimeter statue of the ancient Egyptian king in the valley of Dahuk, 470 kilometres north of Baghdad, near a site that locals have long called Pharaoh's Castle. He said archaeologists from the Dahuk Antiquities Authority believe the statue dates from the mid-14th Century BC. Ahmed said the statue of Tutankhamen showed 'the face of the ancient civilization of Kurdistan and cast light on the ancient relations between pharaonic Egypt and the state of Mitanni.' The kingdom of Mittani occupied roughly the same territory spanning Syria, Iraq, Turkey, and Iran in the 14th Century BC that many Kurds now hope will one day form an independent Kurdistan. 'Historical information indicates familial and political ties between Mittani and Egypt,' Ahmed said. 'The discovery of this statue shows us that the name of Pharaoh's Castle, was not invented out of vacuum, but rather arose out of historical fact,' Ahmed told Akanews. 'This calls for strengthening archaeological research ties between the territory of Kurdistan and the Arab Republic of Egypt.' (c) Deutsche Presse-Agentur
    ***********************************
    The Mittani were the original "horse-whisperers." They spoke a language that was neither Indo-European nor Semitic - it was Hurrian, and an exquisitely detailed horse-training manual originally dictated in that language by the great horse trainer Kikkuli, was translated into Hittite and Akkadian in the 14th century BCE. According to Robert Drews ("The Coming of the Greeks", 90), "[t]he fact of translation into other languages shows how great a value was put upon the expertise of a famous [horse] trainer". This was during the great age of chariot warfare and the Mittani horse-whisperers were in great demand in Egypt, Mesopotamia, Anatolia, and the Levant. In the Hittite language, these horse-training men (a literal translation) were called LU.ashshushshani. The reconstructed proto-Indo-European root word for horse is ekwo, perhaps originally derived from oku. Words descended include equestrian, equine, equitant, from Latin equus, horse; second derivative line of words is hippus, hippocampus, hippocene, hippodrome, hipogriff, hippotamus, from Greek hippos, horse. In Sanskrit (India) this became something like ashwa; in Pahlavi (Persia) asp; in Farsi (Iran) asb. In the Hittite phrase LU.ashshushshani, the PIE root word for horse - ash- is evident. The specially bred long-legged horses that were the most highly coveted to pull these light-weight war chariots were imported from the land that is today Armenia, the same place that, according to Drews, the eight-spoked chariot wheel first appeared in about 1800 BCE. By about 1650 BCE the swift, light-weight war chariot ridden on two strong but aerodynamic eight-spoked wheels enabled the Hkysos to conquer most of Egypt. Personally, I have always thought that the ancient PIE root word for horse - ekwo - and the word Hyksos have a linguistic connection. Some day I hope to have the time to learn more about linguistics, a fascinating field, and etymology. I think learning more about these subjects could yield valuable clues about the true meanings of the names of the ancestors of the chess pieces we use today.

    Thursday, June 26, 2008

    There is NOTHING Sacred Anymore...

    Thefts from mosques in Egypt. Wonder what the Taliban and Mr. Rotting Away Hiding in Caves in Afghanistan have to say about that? And the pissing and moaning continues as nothing is done and "pious" Muslims sell their own cultural heritage to illegal antiquities dealers. Bwwwwaaahhhhh! From news aggregator Archaelogy News (Story from Al-Ahram online 26 June - 2 July 2008 Issue No. 903 Unholy thefts Squabbles between the Supreme Council of Antiquities and the Ministry of Awqaf (religious endowments) are wreaking havoc on the fate of Egypt's Islamic monuments, reports Nevine El-Aref Thefts from Islamic monuments in the Darb Al-Ahmar area have highlighted the problem of security at Cairo's historic mosques. Inlaid wooden panels from the minbars of Ganim Al-Bahlawan and Altinbuga Al-Maridani mosques have been stolen, and a marble relief from the Blue Mosque. Thieves were also caught red handed, attempting to make off with a magnificent ironwork grill window from the sabil kuttab of Rokaya Dudu. Residents of Darb Al-Ahmar suspect a professional local gang, which operates at night, between night and dawn prayers. Ahmed Hassan, who owns a perfume shop in the vicinity of several targeted mosques, said the minbar at Al-Maridani was removed in three phases over 10 days, raising questions as to how seriously the authorities take their responsibility to guard historic sites. The theft of the minbar 's right hand panel was discovered at the time of dawn prayer. A week passed before the left hand panel was removed, and a further two days before the thieves returned to remove the ivory inlaid hood of the minbar. At Ganim Al-Bahlawan robbers removed the decorative elements of the minbar, leaving a plain wooden frame. At Rokaya Dudu sabil kuttab they succeeded in dismantling the iron grill from a window only to be apprehended by local residents who alerted the police. The window is now being held by the Supreme Council of Antiquities (SCA) inspectorate, to be returned to its original location following restoration work. "It's a terrible loss," says Gamal Abdel-Rehim, professor of Islamic monuments at Cairo University's Faculty of Archaeology. The minbar of Ganim Al-Bahlawan was among the most important in any of Cairo's monumental mosques. Abdel-Khaleq Mokhtar, director of monuments in south Cairo, told Al-Ahram Weekly that the SCA was able to abort the theft of the window at the sabil kuttab of Rokaya Dudu because the monument is under the complete supervision of the SCA, which provides a 24-hour security, while the mosques are under the control of the Ministry of Awqaf. "Securing archaeological sites is the responsibility of the authority to which the site is affiliated," he says. Quite how 24-hour security allowed the window to be dismantled in the first place remains a mystery. Yet Abdel-Khaleq insists the SCA secures its own site round the clock, while monuments such as mosques, under bilateral supervision, are guarded only until 4pm. Abdel-Khaleq says the SCA has repeatedly requested that the Ministry of Awqaf tighten security at mosques or else hand over responsibility to the SCA. "Currently the role of the SCA is to restore mosques and then hand them back to the Awqaf. The SCA then makes only periodic checks on the buildings' archaeological features." Sheikh Kamal Abdel-Nasser, director of Awqaf in Cairo, argues that the SCA is shirking its responsibilities. "Why does the SCA refuse to admit responsibility for their own security shortcomings and seek, instead, to blame the mosque guards?" he asks. Abdel-Nasser points out that legally monuments and archaeological sites are all the responsibility of the SCA and not the Awqaf. Furthermore, he adds, the mosque of Ganim Al-Bahlawan has been closed now for two years while restoration work is carried out under the supervision of the SCA and its contractors. "These accusations addressed to the Ministry of Awqaf are an attempt by the SCA to deny its responsibility for what happened." Zahi Hawass, secretary-general of the SCA, will hold a meeting next week with the head of the Awqaf to draw up a security plan for archaeological mosques. "Millions of pounds have been spent restoring these mosques which are then handed back to the Ministry of Awqaf," says Hawass. To tighten security, Hawass believes that the Ministry of Awqaf must provide the names of guards to both the SCA and security forces, and the SCA and Ministry of Awqaf need to cooperate more closely in an attempt to provide 24-hour security. "Securing and preserving Egypt's Islamic monuments is not only the responsibility of the ministries of culture, awqaf, interior, the SCA and the relevant governorate. It is the responsibility of all Egyptians who want to protect their heritage and their history," says Hawass.
    Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...